Charlotte Mason Apologia High School Science
Once again, you are all standing around scratchin’ yer noggins saying, “Huh?” heehee….
A friend was wondering what to use that was more “Charlotte Mason Friendly” than a big science textbook (like Apologia). I just wanted to share my reply to her concern here in case it blesses someone (else… I know my friend, Lori Lynn was blessed by it *smile*):
What we do for Science (using Aologia) is read Dr. Wile’s chapters together… very CM. I read it to them, cuddled up on the couch, then we do the experiments together and have fun (I record my own lab sheet too!) and then we talk about the results before we move on to reading what Dr. Wile has written about “what was supposed to happen”. We use a lapbook system for the “study questions” so they can quiz themselves effectively, then we do the test… it’s been very interactive. I cannot imagine asking my kids to do that HUGE text alone… You can find some interactive hands-on materials for Apologia at Currclick and you can get the lab kits at Sonlight (which can make a difference between facing the experiments confidently or not)… you can find them in the core 7 science they are called NSK and I’m not sure the other one, the other one is the one gears specifically for “General Science”)
I believe that almost anything can be done in a somewhat CM-y way… reading the lessons together and getting excited about it and discussing it with Dad ‘round the dinner table (narrations anyone?) cements the learning. Don’t give up quite yet…
BUT…another resource (with the exception of the first course, which I recommend ONLY if you omit the last lesson) are the connect the thoughts science courses… they are thorough, however NOT faith based (and in my humble opinion it is impossible to separate the two and get a “good” science education… since a good researcher would go to the source of the thing they are studying, right? Well, since God made everything, it seems logical to go to Him about His creation. Ya know?). However, from a completely “separate from God” point of view.. these are excellent. They can also be done as a “read together” then “discuss the questions or do the projects together” kind of way, although it’d be a bit more challenging. You can find them at also at Currclick.
High school science is tough… not tough to understand with the right “teacher”, but a tough “responsibility”… you don’t want to leave your kids short changed, yet it’s hard to make a not-text book type choice and be sure you’ve covered all the basics.
I was also thinking, maybe ask around and see if anyone else in your homeschool community is doing the Apologia and see if maybe you guys could organize “group experiments” or something, your son might be more interested if he knows he’s not alone and has something to look forward to (getting together with some science buddies)? I have the benefit of both my Bigs doing this science together with me, so it makes it a “mini-group” and we’ve had some fun “arguments” over what we think should happen or should HAVE happened (um, the balloon apparently wasn’t *supposed* to explode all over the kitchen – who knew?) and to discuss the lesson together.
I hope you can find something that works for you…
Blessings!
9. October 2008 at 13:35
Your math questions are really hard.
Loved this post! I agree that “almost anything can be done in a somewhat CM-y way”. Just takes a bit of creativity, which you seem to have plenty of. 